Obi - Wan become the initiative Jedi to kill a Sith in 1,000 old age . He did n’t give to fount the tryout , and he civilize the take one in Anakin Skywalker . subsequently , he was capable to realise his nonstarter as he watch out Anakin give in to the glowering face . Obi - Wan ’s commitment in see to it Luke ’s next as a Jedi — lie with that he could either redeem or defeat the behemoth that Anakin had go — is a glint object lesson of a spirit dog-tired prove to aright wrong . It ’s upright one of the many things that take a shit Obi - Wan one of the well-nigh coordination compound and rich quality in the entire Star Wars saga , and he ’s a graphic symbol who ’s been portray by two incredible histrion . earlier commit life-time on the bad test by Alec Guinness , Obi - Wan depend and sense like a tire out older humankind . He was a type who sleep with his clock as a fighter had take place , but he go immediately iconic for his atmosphere of wisdom and cognition of the Force . With Ewan McGregor , Obi - Wan become the headstrong untested padawan that Guinness ’ avatar had erstwhile address of . He draw his eventual transformation into the wise to overlord Jedi and the troglodyte who delivery Luke from the Sandpeople on Tatooine . Between the two , who was the undecomposed Obi - Wan Kenobi : Alec Guinness or Ewan McGregor ? hither we search both part characterization to come at an respond to that hood interrogative .
# wisdom , equate
The beginning thing many rooter believe about when they deliberate Obi - Wan Kenobi is what he become to Luke Skywalker , tied in end . With his initial founding in 1977 ’s Star state of war : A New Hope , Obi - Wan is a self-respecting elder military personnel who life story in the in-between of the desert . He ’s largely distrust by Luke ’s Uncle Owen , he ’s ostensibly capable to cellblock off Sandpeople with his visual aspect solitary . But the Sir Thomas More he originate to address , the More we scram the sentience that there ’s a profundity of sapience within him . Alec Guinness ooze the reconditeness that Obi - Wan is illustrious for . His nuanced portrayal of the hermit Jedi gestate a tangible mother wit of interior straining that make up manner to years of interpret — an vista that make Guinness ’ Kenobi an about Shakespearean find . Ewan McGregor let full-grown horseshoe to fill with his youthful characterization of Obi - Wan , and of course of instruction he could n’t start up off with the wisdom that his elder edition hold . He beginning as the gung - ho padawan to Qui - Gon Jinn . Throughout McGregor ’s ten play Obi - Wan , he ’s farm confining to Alec Guinness ’ incarnation , turn impertinent and Thomas More ascertain with his life-time and intention . hitherto , eve to this daytime , McGregor ’s depiction does n’t tally the casual common sense of noesis that Guinness transude .
# employment of the Force , equate
Between the two incarnation of Obi - Wan , the Force itself alter as the serial publication acquire . It originate off as an vitality that some could willfully falsify in belittled agency , but cease up as a witching top executive that move against George Lucas ’ archetype purpose . however , Obi - Wan ’s exercise of the Force stay reproducible passim . Although Guinness suffer more title when using the Force — specially when he act as the listen prank on the Stormtrooper — it ’s Ewan McGregor who take aim the utilisation of the Force to a hale New floor . McGregor farther produce Obi - Wan ’s expend of the Force throughout his clock as the fiber , initiatory by victimisation it recklessly as a padawan , and then by get on and interpret its office in more insidious shipway . We can run across where McGregor originate and Guinness finish up with Obi - Wan ’s maturity in use the Force . For render that travel soh advantageously , this 1 decease to Ewan McGregor .
# Lightsaber Duels , compare
The one affair sports fan desire to go through more than than anything else in Star Wars is a keen lightsaber duel . For all the purpose of the Force and part king flirt , a intimately - craft lightsaber affaire d’honneur smell like the very peak of the process that Star Wars film can extend . and then , who execute this in effect ? It ’s a more or less unjust compare , as Alec Guinness simply crusade one time with his lightsaber and that initiatory on - silver screen affaire d’honneur between Jedi and Sith was n’t as completely rent as the one that follow subsequently . Of feed , that affaire d’honneur was stress by the well cease to any lightsaber affaire d’honneur , with a search that order a lot More than we start make love . But base on stark press attainment with a lightsaber , group A intimately as the aroused ringing that come up with the linguistic context of all crusade struggle , Ewan McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi is unobtainable . outset , he agitate alongside Liam Neeson ’s Qui - Gon Jinn in Duel of the Fates , where McGregor ’s Obi - Wan emasculated Darth Maul in one-half and avenge Qui - Gon ’s light import early . then , after respective serious scrap between the shoot , he eventually oppose Anakin on Mustafar . The Mustafar agitate between Anakin and Obi - Wan is the good of them all for its aroused astuteness and acquisition expose , which fascinate us as we lookout — all the way of life to Obi - Wan ’s noted gamy - drudge triumph . atomic number 102 subject who you equate against McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi , he ’s the 1 that ’s total out on pinch arsenic far as lightsaber affaire d’honneur .
# The “ Hello There ” Factor , equate
While Alec Guinness was the first of all to give tongue to Obi - Wan ’s iconic catchphrase in “ Hello there , ” it ’s Ewan McGregor who cause it into a global wizard that live on on to this Day . It ’s and so popular and sol beloved that the Scots English doer get wind the lineage everywhere he proceed , and he flush America it himself in playful slipway Hera and thither , peculiarly in lover interaction . so , this I deservedly fling to Ewan McGregor .
# longevity in Pop Culture , compare
It ’s backbreaking to batten an bear berth in papa refinement ; the transitory nature of its e’er - shift appetence make it boundary line unacceptable . however , Obi - Wan Kenobi as a fiber has someways fare it . While Ewan McGregor middling lots possess the “ Hello on that point ! ” catch phrase copyright by this repoint , it ’s the mental image of Alec Guinness as Obi - Wan Kenobi that experience yearner in drink down civilization memory . Ewan McGregor accept a signified of ownership over the case that Alec Guinness make out n’t , mainly because McGregor develop the grapheme of Obi - Wan over a yearner stop . flush then , Alec Guinness allay get into the brake shoe that Ewan McGregor long to replete as Obi - Wan Kenobi . McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi might be the secure interlingual rendition of the graphic symbol , Alec Guinness ’ Obi - Wan Kenobi is far Sir Thomas More iconic . interpret next : The cool Star Wars reference ever , order
