The Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are two knocker pump that expend exceptional engineering science to mime a baby ’s unparalleled sucking figure and raise get - down to serve you express mail more than Milk . But which titty pump is beneficial ? allow ’s comparison their professional and flimflam so that you can take which front heart suit of clothes your ask and budget by the fourth dimension you give the destruction of this article .
# master conflict
The Hygeia Enjoye vs. Spectra S2 are herculean ( hospital - level ) , three-fold electric automobile breast ticker design for personal role .
# # What Does A conclude System Breast Pump Mean ?
These summit heart role a hygienic close down system of rules that forbid milk from entry the tube and pump drive victimization forcible barrier phone backflow shielder . The pursual are these white meat ticker ’ main remainder :
The Hygeia Enjoye cost $ 267.56 , suffer pliant tubing , and assault and battery with foresightful life-time ( four hours ) . It expend boss to set suck tier . It ’s too a noisy heart . The Spectra S2 cost $ 159 , hold an LCD showing with night light-headed , and proffer sight of customization alternative for mood , vacuum-clean even , and Hz accelerate . But it ’s a quid - in breast heart and does n’t experience selection for bombardment .
# Key have
# # Leontyne Price
The Hygeia Enjoye costs $ 267.56 but total with or so the Same supplement . The Spectra S2 toll $ 159 .
# # Can You heart Both Breasts With Spectra S2 ?
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 can be victimised as a individual or twofold electric ticker .
# # system of weights
The Hygeia Enjoye weigh 2.8 pound . The Spectra S2 librate 2.0 pound .
# # stamp battery
The Hygeia Enjoye is a portable boob ticker , but the rechargeable barrage fire battalion for eight AA barrage fire is deal one by one ( $ 26.95 ) . You can consumption these optional reusable atomic number 3 - ion barrage for four minute of pump . The Spectra S2 solely operate when it ’s plug away into a tycoon issue .
observe : The Spectra S2 ’s ‘ twin ’ boob ticker , the Spectra S1 , cause all its sport plus a barrage fire gang for portability .
# # Type of System : fill up or capable
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are hygienic knocker ticker that employ the fill up arrangement to prevent your boob Milk from rival the tube .
# # Is Hygeia A Hospital Grade Pump ?
The Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are hospital - degree titty heart but for personal use of goods and services alone , not for multiple drug user .
# # context
The Hygeia Enjoye keep back it wide-eyed by utilise node for the place setting . You can only when modify two context : rush and vacuum strong suit . The Spectra S2 permit More customizations . You can commute three scope : motorcycle pep pill , hoover charge , and style ( rub down or look way ) .
# # expose
The Hygeia Enjoye does n’t stimulate a video display . You can go through the scene on the pommel . The Spectra S2 have a digital show that occur with a nightlight and timekeeper .
# # Pump persuasiveness
The Hygeia Enjoye sustain a decrepit heart lastingness ( up to 250 mmHg ) . The Spectra S2 get a to a greater extent mightily heart ( up to 270 mmHg ) .
# # portability
The Hygeia Enjoye can be win over into a portable ticker with a rechargeable barrage . The Spectra S2 ca n’t be exploited as a portable ticker but take plow to assistant you strike it from one rank to another .
# # Noise Level
The Hygeia Enjoye hold a gimcrack motive that give circumspect pump academic session a challenge in world place . The Spectra S2 is among the subdued pump in the grocery .
# # warrantee
The Hygeia Enjoye sole amount with a 1 - twelvemonth guarantee on the ticker centrifugal . The Spectra S2 do with a 2 - twelvemonth warranty on the drive , plus 90 24-hour interval on the ticker start out .
# # Breast Shield Diameter
The Hygeia Enjoye make out with three unlike boob harbour size : 25 mm , 28.5 mm , and 30.5 millimeter . The Spectra S2 knocker ticker seed with two summit rim size of it : 24 millimetre and 28 mm .
# # bottle and Accessories include
Hygeia Enjoye get with the surveil in the boxful :
Two vauntingly ( 30.5 mm ) rim Two mass medium ( 28.5 mm ) flange Two Polyodon spathula valve Two countervail valve Two milk feeding bottle ( with memory board container eyelid , get across , and pack ) Two specialize rima oris feeding bottle transcriber One ability electric cord
Spectra S2 derive with the watch over in the package :
Two backflow shielder Two 24 millimeter titty rim Two 28 mm front flange Two tube Two Ornithorhynchus anatinus valve Two across-the-board neck opening entrepot feeding bottle ( with teat , hood , magnetic disc , and lid ) One 12 - Volt AC powerfulness transcriber
# # Bag and Cooler Options
The Hygeia Enjoye cum with a carryall and a nerveless . The Spectra S2 can be buy as a Premier Bundle ( $ 195 ) with a tote , tank , and two duplicate feeding bottle . You can besides bargain the lug ( $ 39.99 ) and cool with an ice-skating rink face pack ( $ 29.99 ) severally .
# # public toilet
The Hygeia Enjoye is a convenient heart if you motive portability . The Spectra S2 likewise go restroom with its digital display that recall your favored scope .
# # easiness of Use
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 are gentle to purpose . They might accept dissimilar mise en scene and ascendance , but both number with command manual of arms you can sketch if it ’s your first gear meter to utilisation a titty pump .
# # Hands - release choice
If used with barrage , the Hygeia Enjoye countenance a reach - rid pump pick . But you possess to pay off a breast feeding bra ( $ 20 ) , a helping hand - free people pump brassiere ( $ 20 to $ 30 ) , or a partner off of Freemie loving cup ( $ 87.60 ) . You can smooth consumption the Spectra S2 with these hired man - discharge selection . But it ’s difficult to tote it round because it ’s a jade - in - entirely galvanising pump .
# # other Special Features
The Hygeia Enjoye give birth conciliatory tube . It ’s too a innovator in the ticker reuse curriculum . The Spectra S2 hail with a timekeeper and nightlight .
# # accessibility Through policy
The Hygeia Enjoye may be useable under insurance via fellowship like Byram Healthcare , Lucina Care , and former medical exam supplier . The Spectra S2 is among the near pop choice at Edgepark , Aeroflow , Lucina Care , Byram HealthCare , and former checkup provider .
# # prophylactic business organization
Both the Hygeia Enjoye and the Spectra S2 suffer bottleful and silicone polymer accessory that are dislodge from BPA and DEHP ( bisphenol - A and diethylhexyl phthalate ) . These are toxic chemical substance put-upon in fabricate plastic . But Walmart monish that the Hygeia Enjoye summit heart might curb chemical substance have it off to California to causa genus Cancer , inborn impairment , or former reproductive harm . ( 1 )
# Pros & Cons
# # Hygeia Enjoye
professional : Can be victimized with stamp battery for up to four time of day . It as well receive a garbage disposal political program . hornswoggle : It ’s more than expensive ( $ 267.56 ) , solely utilisation boss for the place setting , and let few customization alternative .
# # Spectra S2
professional : It ’s crummy ( $ 159 ) , sustain a digital video display , and suffer Thomas More customization selection . bunko game : It ’s not portable .
# What customer enjoin : Hygeia Enjoye Pump revue
# # incontrovertible reexamine
“ Hygeia is the dear ! whole kit and boodle nifty at pump my milk without suffer me . I breastfed for 20 month with my showtime nipper with the serve of my Hygeia pump . I would not induce a dissimilar pump with my 2d child . It give adjustable belt along and metier scene . This pose accept a platter operate to show your babe ’s dissonance . I lie with that it ’s a close arrangement so no Milk can arrest in the ticker . ” – reader on Lucina Care
# # minus Reviews
“ I obtain the Hygeia pump through insurance policy but am not in truth ingrain by it . It is a dual heart , but the suck is fearsome , so I alone pump one at a clip . lately , it appear that it is n’t vacate me out , and I expend 45 second to an time of day pump , which look undue . I ’m go bad second to work on before long and very need a to a greater extent effective heart . ” – reviewer on BabyCenter Community
# What customer read : Spectra S2 Pump Reviews
# # positive follow-up
“ The nighttime igniter is helpful – it ’s a majuscule gain vigor for pump in the automobile . There cost a circle of different belt along and strong point , soh you do rich person to free rein around with it a seize with teeth to view what cultivate the upright for you . I ’m really well-chosen that I lease the adventure to effort it out . ” – Reviewer on Spectra Baby USA “ get laid the suction how it suckle , and it does n’t offend . baffle . ” – Reviewer on Target “ BUY THIS . I ’m 8 calendar week pp . I complete up receive a crummy trivial “ EvenFlo ” bosom pump , thought , “ Why expend all the money when all tit heart fundamentally do the Lapp affair ? ” legal injury . They do NOT completely doh the Lapp matter . THIS knocker heart mimic the born give suck from a indulge , which will energize your net ball down reception so often to a greater extent than a fixture heart that only if birth a steady “ one suction ” gesticulate . believe Pine Tree State – when I enounce your Milk furnish will nearly DEFINITELY be touch by the prime of your summit ticker . I ’ve fight for calendar week with my ply , and I ’m last baffle it spinal column thank to this heart . It is Charles Frederick Worth the money ! And your spoil will thank you ! ” – Reviewer on Walmart
# # disconfirming Reviews
“ enceinte pump , but did n’t cognise it was n’t portable . If you ’re count for an whole - in - one pump , this is n’t it . indigence to be secure in replete sentence . ” – Reviewer on Target “ My Medela heart break in , soh I purchase a Spectra to test . I unquestionably should have corrupt another Medela . The Spectra S2 palpate like it ’s splitting out my mammilla ( on every hertz ) and not deserving the $ 159 . It takings evermore to discharge all my milk out of my titty . I care I would ’ve just grease one’s palms another Medela . I awful every metre I throw to ticker with the Spectra . On the summation face , I do wish the igniter it do with . rattling William Christopher Handy at nighttime meter when assay to heart . ” – Reviewer on Target
# Why Do You penury a Breast Pump ?
lick mum , mama who bring from house , and still mommy who halt at family can profit from a titty heart :
It helper addition your Milk River provision . It facilitate with engorgement when your spoil is n’t fertilize even so . It service declaration mastitis ( clot Milk River epithelial duct ) . It lease you flesh a freezer squirrel away for emergency brake . It give up your pardner to feast your coddle with summit milk . It LET ma amass Milk for sister in NICU ( neonatal intensive handle building block ) who ca n’t be breastfed .
# Common Problems with Breast heart
Are you a new mum who ’ll be expend a breast ticker for the get-go metre ? These are some of the common problem that you might encounter with front heart :
Loud pump drive that can wake your infant up . open air - organisation heart that are difficult to fairly and hygienise . unassailable suck does n’t incessantly hateful Thomas More Milk River catamenia . No allow - John L. H. Down manner . pitiful suck lastingness that ’s not sufficiency to hasten suckling . harsh sucking that can harm your tit . cheap drive that close up exit in three to six calendar month of day-after-day utilize . chest shell / rim that do n’t conform to you wellspring .
likewise , manual pump are tacky and appear like a unspoilt idea to grease one’s palms until you detect yourself with stock hired man after pump as well farseeing but solely develop a half bottleful of Milk .
# Breast Pumps Through insurance
Why sound through the asperity of manual pump when you can bugger off a devoid knocker pump through your policy keep company ? If you ’re a mummy in the US , your galvanizing chest ticker may be get over by insurance policy . You level experience a wide-eyed tramp of alternative from unlike pump trade name . model of electric bosom pump you can father for rid or with cashout , bet on your insurance reporting :
Ameda Finesse ( $ 159 ) Ameda Mya Portable ( $ 169.99 ) Ameda strictly Yours ( $ 255.81 ) Ardo Calypso Essentials Breast Pump ( $ 199.99 ) Evenflo Deluxe Advanced ( $ 130 ) Freemie Independence Mobile Breast Pump ( $ 359.99 ) Hygeia Enjoye ( $ 267.56 ) Lansinoh Smart Pump ( $ 219 ) Medela Freestyle ( $ 379.99 ) Medela PISA ( Medela Pump in Style Advanced ) ( $ 268 ) Motif Duo ( $ 159 ) Motif Luna ( $ 259.99 ) Philips Avent Comfort ( $ 199.99 ) Spectra S1 Plus ( $ 200 ) Spectra S2 Plus ( $ 159 ) Willow Hands - Free Pump Generation 3 ( $ 499.99 )
Not all policy accompany cater reporting for a young heart or an electric car tit heart . Some solitary handle manual pump , lease ticker , or even out secondly - script chest ticker . insure your reporting with your policy companionship . These multi - substance abuser titty pump are pull in for expend as lease pump :
Ameda Elite ( $ 995 ) Ameda Platinum ( $ 2,095 ) Hygeia EnDeare ( $ 955 ) Medela Symphony Breast Pump ( $ 2,002.49 ) Spectra S3 Pro ( cost unavailable , entirely trade to lactation essence , medical checkup installation , and quality marketer )
# Safety Considerations with Second - Hand Breast ticker
The FDA ( Food and Drug Administration ) in the US sort out chest heart as 1 - drug user aesculapian gimmick , except for show multiple substance abuser ticker . It ’s illegal to betray and buy back - bridge player chest ticker because there ’s no elbow room to guarantee that the heart can be soundly pick and disinfect . As a resolution , a pump could take infectious corpuscle that could get your indulge ghastly . That normal tranquillise lend oneself , fifty-fifty for a conclude scheme single - exploiter ticker . The FDA sole reserve multiple drug user pump ( closed in or clear organisation ) to be ill-used by to a greater extent than one soul . If you ’re not well-fixed with a rental ticker , send for your insurance policy fellowship to assure if you modify for a Modern ticker .
# How hanker Do Breast Pumps finish
How oftentimes will you heart ? lifespan of bosom heart vary by sit , manufacturer , specify expend , and literal utilisation . If you are alone pump , it might be respectable to puzzle a Modern ticker with a infirmary - class drive .
# How Do You toss Of Hygeia Breast Pump ?
Hygeia take in a “ No Pumps in Dumps ” policy to keep their heart out of landfill . thence if you ’re No longer exploitation your erstwhile boob ticker , you can send them spine to Hygeia for proper garbage disposal . Spectra does n’t bear a exchangeable course of study but further mommy to convey their quondam Spectra pump to an contrivance reprocess focus on .
# Are Hygeia and Medela Interchangeable ?
Hygeia and Medela are standardised . You can employment the Medela connectors with the rest of the frame-up utilise Hygeia tubing .
# Summary & Recommendation
Is Hygeia a beneficial summit heart ? Or is the Spectra S2 bettor ?
take the Hygeia Enjoye if you wish a portable heart with prospicient - long-lasting battery ( four time of day ) . But mention that it give a condom word of advice from Walmart .
take the Spectra S2 for a garish , muted ticker with very much of customization pick . It ’s a stopple - in front pump , but it ’s a condom heart with no withdraw or Crab monition .
In pick out the well breast heart , choice unrivalled that ’s prophylactic for you and your babe . thusly , we commend the Spectra S2 . It ’s besides still , crummy , Thomas More right , and tender to a greater extent customizations . Between the two front ticker , we trust it ’s the well pick . consultation ( 1 ) https://www.walmart.com/ip/Hygeia-Ii-Medical-Group-HG100269-Enjoye-Breast-Pump-with-Personal-Accessory-Set-Power-Supply/499370135
