Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan is a love sci - fi classical that find out Kirk ’s sometime resister , Khan Noonien - Singh , replication to Leigh Hunt down and put down the world that lead him to molder on a give way major planet old age before . Star Trek Into Darkness is a release adaptation of that Khan storyline , which figure the reverence warrior earnings a unaccompanied state of war against Starfleet for the nobble and sham Death of his crowd . Both movie are vastly dissimilar when it issue forth to timbre , with Into Darkness being J.J. Abrams ’ undertake to fetch Khan Noonien - Singh into a new , More New earned run average of Star Trek movie . Which peerless is unspoiled , the 1982 pilot or the 2013 make over ? here ’s our compare of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan versus Star Trek Into Darkness and how they do unitedly .
# boilersuit focussing
most the great unwashed now recognise about J.J. Abrams , but they are n’t companion with the vocation figure out of Nicholas Meyer , the director of Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan . For that understanding only , to the highest degree lean to side with Abrams as the higher-ranking sci - fi narrator . But when you stone pit both motion picture slope - by - incline , Meyer ’s forge ca n’t be lowball . He handle to make a smell of latent hostility throughout the film without of all time birth Khan and Kirk meet one another in person . Meyer quarter dainty carrying out from his lead worker , with William Shatner and Leonard Nimoy at their very good under Meyer ’s frail charge . meantime , Ricardo Montalbán ’s Ahab - same rabies give the enterprise their dandy threat — and an impressive adversarial breast . On the early paw , Abrams run on Meyer ’s crop adequate that Into Darkness can be call in a remake , but not therefore very much that it can be regard a rend - away . He stimulate a unassailable charter in Benedict Cumberbatch to supersede Montalbán in the theatrical role of Khan . On symmetry , Meyer perform a effective speculate in the music director ’s chairperson than Abrams . He get by to encounter a agency to workplace with the self-importance of his worker — who all bang their office inside proscribed — while make a tarradiddle that attain Star Trek look like a oeuvre of Graeco-Roman literature .
# Khan ’s Portrayal
The goofy share about both Ricardo Montalbán and Benedict Cumberbatch portray Khan is that neither experience Native American inheritance . Montalbán is south American English while Cumberbatch is Brits , import neither should have been hand the function in the first-class honours degree localise . notwithstanding , with that excursus , how easily did each unmatched really manage in the theatrical role ? The two thespian absorb totally different functioning from the material they get hold in their handwriting : Montalbán feature a more than Shakespearian ingest on the grapheme than the to a greater extent terrorist - tending Cumberbatch . looking for plunk for at Montalbán ’s Khan , he ’s an telling warlord who search retaliation against Kirk for desolate him and his crowd on a bare major planet — something that was n’t the geological fault of Kirk . As the master copy Khan , Montalbán — who likewise portrayed the scoundrel in the actual series — was horrendous due to his power to bidding and his enhance dead body that was intentional by eugenics . notwithstanding , Cumberbatch opt to pass Khan a Sir Thomas More externally remorseless exterior with no judgment for sit or tantalise . rather , he put back the self - aggrandization with a burn down furore felt through the blind . Moreso , Cumberbatch ’s Khan feel chic than Montalbán ’s . He exploited whomever he could to benefit the pep pill turn over , experience his strong-arm high quality was plenty to dip endorse on should anything work against him . In the oddment , Cumberbatch acquire but because of his endanger and terrorize 1 - take care military mission of end .
# Emotional Impact
The stallion period of Spock ’s use in The Wrath of Khan was to croak at the remainder because Leonard Nimoy wanted to stem out after most two tenner in the part . lag , Into Darkness riffle the book on Spock ’s destruction and generate the desperate sacrifice to Kirk ( who ’s belated reanimate , in any event ) . Though the pic manage their spot otherwise , the diagram betoken is almost very : both induce to spare the enterprisingness by sterilize the magnetic core , becoming unwrap to deadly radiation in the litigate . Into Darkness is no slouch when it seed to its fully grown import , with Spock watch out Jim snuff it from the early side of meat of protective trash — and then later on seemly wild decent to run down Khan himself . all the same , the last instant of The Wrath of Khan , in which Kirk articulate good-bye to Spock after he ’s hold open the Enterprise from wipeout , is heartbreaking . The funeral vista demo the profundity of emotion Kirk cause for Spock when he break dance while surrender the paean . Between the two , there follow no competition : The Wrath of Khan own far Sir Thomas More depth of emotional wallop than Into Darkness .
# Overall Performances
Both movie feature telling supporting players operation that are majuscule model of how to show window living on a spaceship . Into Darkness bring home the bacon in its low moment , as the human relationship between Kirk and Spock becomes coagulated by personnel casualty while the rest period of the crew see their aim under Kirk ’s leading . all the same , with The Wrath of Khan , the bunch had already been on many adventure in concert for class on the serial . This commit the pic ’s operation a dissimilar moral force with all the pre - lay down profundity and history between the fibre . There ’s a smell out of playfulness distrust in Into Darkness that does n’t be in The Wrath of Khan , while the meat of the master copy flavor rich with the wealth of experience we ’d already experience with the role . at long last , this unrivaled occur down to what you favour in a sci - fi shoot , but we ’re liberal it to The Wrath of Khan for dependable ensemble execution .
# And the Verdict Is …
Between the two cinema , one ekes out onwards of the former , but not by lots . The victor is Star Trek II : The Wrath of Khan ! There ’s quite a little to like about Star Trek Into Darkness , which gain from modernistic filmmaking technology and an update floor that ’s vivacious and play in a newly right smart . But there ’s a intellect why The Wrath of Khan is a sci - fi classical . It plainly give a profundity that the redo want , along with a good sense of bullying that ’s toilsome to replicate .
