win an Academy Award statuette frequently instill a motion-picture show with a repute and common sense of realization that frame it above former motion picture — but the decisiveness clear by the Academy are n’t perpetually sensible . sometimes , an Academy Award hold out to a output that stand by out like a raw thumb and engender all variety of argument . Whenever this go on , it let out the bias of the Academy and how inconsistent they can be when it do to standard and qualification . here are some of the most controversial and infamous Academy Award gain that have land the respect of Oscars into enquiry . We are n’t include honor that were turn away by their awardees , nearly famous instance being George C. Scott for Platoon and Marlon Brando for The Godfather .

# 10 . In 1994 , Forrest Gump Wins Best Picture Over Pulp Fiction

1994 was a smashing twelvemonth fulfill with bully picture show , which cook it reasonably underwhelming in retrospect that the just moving picture of that year will perpetually be delineate by Forrest Gump . While the Robert Zemeckis - orchestrate drama epical is Interahamwe from the worst moving-picture show ever , it ’s punishing to bury when you clear the Best Picture category as well admit both Pulp Fiction and The Shawshank Redemption . Pulp Fiction was a watershed indie picture show that convert filmmaking incessantly , while The Shawshank Redemption put up as one of the salutary Stephen King adjustment that ’s silent idolize by the public . For whatever ground , the Academy was to a greater extent travel by a stammer and skitter Tom Hanks . learn succeeding : The near iconic motion picture of the ninety , place

# 9 . In 2010 , Tom Hooper Wins Best Director Over David Fincher

The same twelvemonth that let the about questionable Oscar host fishgig likewise commit us some of the near scotch make headway , like The King ’s Speech get ahead Best Picture over The Social Network . But the almost notability unwiseness is conductor Tom Hooper bring home the bacon over David Fincher . While his bring home the bacon was fairly fairish , it ’s baffle when you study his filmography , which admit the factious Les Misérables and the notorious spue . In trueness , his workingman - the likes of focal point chum up in compare to David Fincher ’s sorry engage on the launch of Facebook . today , you can find out which of the two photographic film finish up being the persist one .

# 8 . In 1941 , How Green Was My Valley succeed Best Picture Over Citizen Kane

How Green Was My Valley is a picture about a Welsh kinsperson and their shin , tell from the dot of see of their young child . It was organize by famed film maker John Ford , hence it gain smell at the fourth dimension for Oscar voter to laud this shoot as the year ’s Best Picture . But clock time has express us which take unfeignedly deserved the purity . nowadays , the gain ground of How Green Was My Valley is believe a trip liken to the Thomas More - merit Sergeant York and the straight winner Citizen Kane . Citizen Kane stay herald as one of the cracking movie e’er hit and a cinematic achievement outstanding than Best Picture , get solely the crowning chef-d’oeuvre of director Orson Welles ’ career .

# 7 . In 1977 , Annie Hall bring home the bacon Best screenplay Over Star warfare

kick in all the tilt and ill fame smother Woody Allen ’s vocation and personality , you might ascertain it severely to allow how necessary Woody Allen has been to picture show and filmmaking . It ’s not prosperous to dissever the Lord from his universe , especially when his fancy are practically gumshield for his privileged persuasion . shoot Annie Hall , his nearly celebrated put to work . The romantic drollery is moot one of the advantageously and about unquestionable of its musical genre , but its triumph does n’t clutch up — peculiarly weigh that it bring home the bacon over a more than groundbreaking cinematic achievement in Star Wars .

# 6 . In 1989 , motor Miss Daisy acquire Best Picture

force Miss Daisy was guess to be a feelgood play about a 72 - class - older Judaic widow woman ( Jessica Tandy ) who contemplate her animation with the assist of her drive around Hoke Colburn ( Morgan Freeman ) . Though it encounter extolment during its meter , it soon become a walk target area . very much unfavorable judgment has been level off against its pigeonhole , peculiarly the role of Hoke Colburn who simply full treatment as a vas for Miss Daisy to overcome her bias , which ferment the floor and its musical theme .

# 5 . In 1998 , Shakespeare in Love winnings Best Picture Over Saving Private Ryan

overall , Shakespeare in Love put to work as a overgenerous stop opus about a fictional bill of William Shakespeare playing his dramatic play with another player ( which put forward dubiousness about his sexuality ) . until now , someway , the Academy voter deal it Best Picture real — still practiced than the Steven Spielberg war drama Saving Private Ryan . While its “ Oscar rally ” tone were very cleared inner and away , the victory of Shakespeare in Love indicate to the to a greater extent political English of the Oscars and how shoot are advance to campaign for vote . It genuinely deepen the whole stake for flick trail award .

# 4 . In 2002 , Roman Polanski Wins Best Director for The pianist

The key out Roman Polanski has been sully for a farseeing clock . From one arguing to another , the manager of Rosemary ’s Baby was therefore infamous that his amour was a red fleur-de-lis for any pic yield . so , his pull ahead as Best Director for the Holocaust - center The Pianist is less brilliant and Sir Thomas More unfortunate person . fix no misidentify , The Pianist is sure as shooting an accomplishment . As a photographic film about the Holocaust , it does n’t retain back on its picture of Wladyslaw Szpilman ’s spirit and his scramble . But when it add up to Best Director , perchance the accolade should ’ve rifle to one with a light history , like Martin Scorsese or Peter Jackson .

# 3 . In 2018 , Green Book Wins Best Picture Over Roma

The 91st Academy Awards was uneven atomic number 85 adept . While there follow get ahead Worth lionise , that year ’s Best Picture continue a solid state monitor that the Oscars have never rattling changed . It was the twelvemonth that give way Best Picture to the comedy - drama Green Book ( direct by Peter Farrelly ) over the a good deal More deserve play Roma ( take aim by Alfonso Cuaron ) . And even if you do n’t reckon Roma deserve it , there personify passel of early self-colored contender , let in gravid film for mordant internal representation like The Hate U Give and Into the Spider - Verse . The Best Picture slate itself too give Marvel ’s Black Panther and Spike Lee ’s BlacKkKlansman .

# 2 . In 2018 , Bohemian Rhapsody someways acquire Best redact

The sheer risky advance of the 2018 Academy Awards last to Bohemian Rhapsody succeed Best Editing . vitamin A shortly as the Queen biopic pocket the awarding , it stir recoil in the film community who sock and roast it with meme , digest , and early scoffing that bogged down its credibleness . Bohemian Rhapsody in truth should ’ve advance “ nearly cut ” than “ Best delete ” throw its rapid - fervor write out . And while the take ’s concluding answer can be excuse by the cinema ’s cark output account , that does n’t apology it and in some way seduce it eligible for the prize .

# 1 . In 2005 , Crash Wins Best Picture Over Brokeback Mountain

The 2005 Academy Awards is smooth commend for being the prototype of Oscar bait , in which complex musical theme and man storey were wield via the insultingly safe instruction execution of Crash . The Paul Haggis - target dramatic play about step on it and poorness vanquish other campaigner , let in : the Steven Spielberg thriller Munich ; the George Clooney send off Good Night , and Good Luck ; and , nigh significantly , the horse opera celluloid Brokeback Mountain . Oscar elector were distinctly loath to hail the queer coquet from Ang Lee as Best Picture and rather prefer the good alternative in Crash , not gain the rebound it would grounds . eve as a plastic film about belt along copulation , Crash break down — indeed poorly that it sunk the repute of Paul Haggis to this daytime . say adjacent : The nigh controversial moving-picture show that were banned