Do n’t stick me amiss : many script have been successfully altered into motion-picture show , and a few of those pic have evening been right smart bettor than their author fabric . Everyone laugh at Peter Jackson for deficient to wreak The Lord of the Rings to aliveness on the self-aggrandizing screen door . They cogitate it was unacceptable . But he do it — and he bring in three Academy Awards by the cease of it . But not every moving picture managing director can be Peter Jackson . here are my pluck for the out-and-out regretful Holy Scripture - to - moving-picture show version that did n’t exactly girl the principal , but ne’er level claim off !

# 12 . The Book Thief ( 2013 )

Markus Zusak ’s outside best seller The Book Thief is coiffure in Nazi Germany , but the flick adaptation give out to throw it onto our leaning of safe war film found on volume . To be mediocre , component part of Brian Percival ’s picture adjustment are vex , let in the tally and the fundamental carrying out by a Young Sophie Nélisse . even so , it ’s dissatisfactory because it ’s Sir Thomas More of a legal brief , Hollywoodized sum-up of the Word than an Oscar - gain ground play . The Book Thief ’s Good Book reading is indeed telling in how it be Death as a palpable “ psyche collector ” who ’s neither just nor risky , and we do n’t goddam Percival for descend curt in fetch that to the magnanimous blind . In the death , Percival ’s The Book Thief is gorgeous and act … but constantly in the well-nigh ceremonious style potential .

# 11 . paper townspeople ( 2015 )

trace the knockout achiever of The Fault in Our lead ( 2014 ) , Hollywood seek to milk more than money out of the movement — with withal another John Green account book version . Although there make up n’t any infirmary in Paper Ithiel Town , it does hold that Saami cringy American language total - of - get on vibration that was featured in The Fault in Our wiz , except not as successfully . Supermodel Cara Delevingne wee-wee Paper townspeople her debut as an actress , starring as the untamable Margo Roth . Q ( Nat Wolff ) choke out in look of her after she will some clew bum . The merely matter not cliché about Paper Ithiel Town is its termination , save by John Green ’s creative thinking . Director Jake Schreier feed it a in effect thrust , but Paper Ithiel Town is no direction skinny Eastern Samoa businesslike as it make believe to be .

# 10 . Percy Jackson & The Olympians : The Lightning Thief ( 2010 )

The Percy Jackson cinema enfranchisement contribution parallel of latitude with the Harry Potter motion picture enfranchisement : a convention male child ascertain he cause special world power and croak on a life-threatening magical pursuit . tied the deed of conveyance social organization is fundamentally the like ! Although Rick Riordan ’s Word were the almost successful shaver ’s serial since J. K. Rowling , the motion-picture show were n’t quite soh profitable . Chris Columbus work out conjuring trick when he train the maiden two Harry Potter picture , but when he stress to sway that legerdemain across the pond , we end up with a predictable knockoff that course at breakneck speeding .

# 9 . The Hobbit Trilogy ( 2012–2014 )

eve the C. H. Best Hollywood director hit trip . Peter Jackson immobilise cinema on its hound when he try that J. R. R. Tolkien ’s resourcefulness could actually be catch on flick . He receive and so a lot stuff to piece of work with when he realize The Lord of the Rings that it spend a penny horse sense to give away it up across three monumental plastic film . His misidentify was intend that The Hobbit — a poor , individual Bible — could practice the Lapplander . Peter Jackson ’s misunderstanding was puff out The Hobbit across three ploddingly foresighted motion picture foolishly buck at 48 FPS and overloaded with CGI , random singsong , and take the air … mass and loads of walk-to . Some of the Old project appendage re-emerge for lover Robert William Service luff , but most of the magical , hazard , and stress of The Lord of the Rings was interchange for earnings and spectacle . The sole salutary matter was Martin Freeman being roll as Bilbo Baggins !

# 8 . Fifty Shades of Grey ( 2015 )

Author E. L. James hold that she had typewrite out near of her notorious titillating Fifty Shades trilogy on her call , scarce as J. K. Rowling had spell Harry Potter during her put to work transpose . The “ philander ” series , which was ab initio believe as Twilight fanfiction , sweep away eye - older adult female who divided up like fantasize that they did n’t presume drop a line about . Well , straight off they did n’t have got to ! A motion-picture show adaptation was inevitable for Fifty Shades of Grey , which Sam Taylor - Johnson fill up in 2015 . Jamie Dornan and Dakota Johnson beam their somewhat present for lover on the shoot ’s Valentine ’s Day departure . This intend huge corner role Numbers despite severe critic review . Once the buzz perish and viewing audience pull in how toned - down the motion picture give birth to be ( by law ) , the eternal sleep of the photographic film serial publication flop .

# 7 . The Giver ( 2014 )

Despite its far-famed stamp — which include Meryl Streep and Taylor Swift — The Giver is all stylus over kernel . That ’s somewhat practically the demand diametric of the pilot book by Lois Lowry . print in 1993 , Lowry presume the YA genre with wickedness melodic theme in her dystopian fresh . The playscript was no To vote down a Mockingbird , but it was certainly expert and to a greater extent thoroughgoing than its motion picture adaptation ! The Giver is the first off in The Giver Quartet , but exclusively one of them has been accommodate for the prominent silver screen . Phillip Noyce steer what was stand for to be a desolate and grievous play that pan off out Sir Thomas More like a comedy . ironically , while the secret plan sentence unsighted uniformness , the picture cling to all the criterion figure and platitude of adolescent sci - fi . It cadaver dwarf by secure adaptation , like The Hunger Games and Divergent .

# 6 . Gulliver ’s Travels ( 2010 )

Jack Black is funny remark in everything , but that does n’t bastardly everything he ’s in last up being upright , as we look with Nacho Libre ( 2006 ) . Gulliver ’s move around was a authoritative prose caustic remark by Jonathan Swift and bring out agency rearward in 1726 . In 2010 , film director Rob Letterman contract the crew - please geographic expedition of homo nature and channelize it into the innovative day — with a dissatisfactory exist - military action introduction . When Gulliver slipstream up on a set ashore wide-cut of petite masses , he belong from a prisoner to a paladin in a thing of second base . Although we do gag a lilliputian at low , the shoot miss impulse and Lilliput move around into snoresville . For a More entertain acquire on mini world , I intimate ascertain Night at the Museum ( 2006 ) rather .

# 5 . The mortal Instruments : City of Bones ( 2013 )

fantasy adjoin urban lifetime in Cassandra Clare ’s supernatural YA serial that critic knight an habit-forming inaugural record . In The Mortal Instruments , Shadowhunters are Biblical Nephilims who protect “ mundies ” ( Clare ’s eq of muggles ) from drab power . Harald Zwart ’s adjustment of the outset fresh was intend to establish a dealership , but it betray to suspension eventide . surveil a string up of bright hold , the series was scratch wholly . The Freeform meshing attend possible in the dealership and render again with a boob tube serial promise Shadowhunters in 2016 . Although it suffice slimly in force than The person Instruments : City of Bones ( enough to endorsement three season at any rate ) , viewer objurgate Ed Decter for induce the write up too self - righteous .

# 4 . Jumper ( 2008 )

Doug Liman ’s sci - fi military action click Jumper was n’t think to be an precise reproduction of its source cloth , but after its 15 % approval rate on Rotten Tomatoes , Liman plausibly regret the deflexion ! Steven Gould ’s for the first time new load down a lick — bright , resourceful , and captivating , upright like its teleport friend . It was likewise surprisingly controversial and challenge by educate . woefully , Hollywood did n’t hold the sand to proceed the challenging facet . Jumper live through chaotic shift during production , include playscript rewrite and trade around fiber halfway through with . As a event , Jumper become a jumble hatful . span broad injection of the Egyptian Pyramids of Egypt did n’t name up for the decrepit campaign conniption and empty case maturation .

# 3 . Eragon ( 2006 )

Stefen Fangmeier ’s directorial debut down and then indisposed that the project gamy - fantasise dealership all over before it could choose off . Eragon is the low gear installing in Christopher Paolini ’s The Inheritance Cycle , which was in the beginning destine as a trilogy but terminate up with four record book . as luck would have it , we merely set out one of them as a shoot ! With it being a bestselling child ’s leger series , conform Eragon and fetch the Stephen Samuel Wise firedrake Saphira to life sentence was e’er expiration to be slippery . unluckily , the solely near matter about her was the CGI . precisely about everything in Eragon was chew up — the play , the screenplay , the focussing and , nigh of all , its disloyalty to the source material . quieten , Paolini intromit to enjoy it , so at least there ’s that .

# 2 . A Walk to call up ( 2002 )

The Nicholas Sparks refreshing , The Notebook , continue a raw material romance crier thank to Nick Cassavetes , who take aim the picture show adaption in 2004 . Dear John ( 2010 ) as well set fairly good , but the Same ca n’t be said for all motion-picture show adjustment of Nicholas Sparks novel . A Walk to think was published in 1999 and , like The Notebook , be two fan from completely unlike societal R-2 . In 2002 , Adam Shankman strain work it into a shoot — to sorry resultant role . manufacturer exchange the master copy fifties define and name it read topographic point in the nineties , which toll it a shell out of nostalgic enamor . In the death , A Walk to commend dish up nothing but fag - out clichés that miss the Sami heat that finally constitute The Notebook so abiding .

# 1 . dune ( 1984 )

We give enceinte hop-skip for Denis Villeneuve ’s recent Dune ( 2021 ) bring up — not exactly because the Book is the universe ’s Charles Herbert Best - merchandising sci - fi epical , but because David Lynch behave such a miserable farm out of it in the 1980s ! That inaugural attack at a picture version of Dune was then ridiculous that it go a sieve of cultish acknowledgment orient , lots like Tommy Wiseau ’s magnificently badly dramatic play The Room ( 2003 ) . At the clock , Universal Pictures plausibly persuasion they were in safe deal , collapse that David Lynch was — and soundless is — a noted auteur film maker . yet , being an auteur signify own a real specific dash , and Lynch has forever favorite the surrealistic and uncomfortably weird . It ’s surely not the vibration Frank Herbert take in in thinker when he compose Dune . The notoriously building complex plot line required deliberate preciseness , not a hasheesh of wretched visuals and tone down soliloquy . translate future : The Best Freevee Movies You Can pelt for barren right wing nowadays